When accidents happen, figuring out who is responsible can be surprisingly complicated. Here's how liability really works.
Electric scooters are everywhere in California, especially in dense cities like San Francisco. They're marketed as a convenient, fun way to get around—but when accidents happen, figuring out who is responsible can be surprisingly complicated.
Unlike traditional car accidents, scooter injury cases often involve multiple potential defendants, each pointing the finger at someone else.
Here's how liability really works.
Electric scooters fall into a gray area between pedestrians, bicycles, and motor vehicles. As a result, scooter accident claims can involve:
Insurance companies often exploit this complexity to delay or deny claims.
Many scooter crashes are caused by factors outside the rider's control, including:
Cars failing to yield or turning suddenly
Poor road conditions, potholes, or uneven pavement
Debris or construction hazards
Defective brakes or malfunctioning scooters
Poorly designed bike lanes or traffic flow
Drivers opening car doors into scooter riders
Determining liability requires looking closely at where and why the accident happened.
Drivers owe scooter riders the same duty of care they owe cyclists and pedestrians.
A driver may be liable if they:
Even when a scooter rider is not in a bike lane, drivers are still required to operate safely.
Scooter rental companies may be responsible if the accident involved:
While scooter companies often rely on liability waivers in their apps, those waivers do not automatically protect them from negligence claims, especially involving unsafe equipment.
Cities and public entities may be liable when injuries are caused by:
⚠️ Important Deadline Alert
Claims against government entities follow strict deadlines and procedures. In California, missing these deadlines can permanently bar a claim—sometimes in as little as six months.
Insurance companies often argue that scooter riders:
California uses a comparative negligence system. This means an injured rider can still recover compensation even if they are partially at fault.
Fault only reduces recovery—it does not eliminate it.
Because scooters offer little stability or protection, injuries are often serious, including:
Traumatic brain injuries
Wrist, arm, and shoulder fractures
Facial injuries and dental damage
Knee and ankle injuries
Road rash and permanent scarring
Medical treatment, missed work, and long-term effects can quickly become overwhelming.
If you're injured, taking these steps can protect your rights and strengthen your claim:
Even if you feel fine, some injuries may not be immediately apparent. Seek medical attention right away.
Take photos of the accident location, road conditions, scooter damage, and your injuries. Note the scooter ID number.
Look for security cameras, dashcams, or people who saw what happened. Get contact information from witnesses.
Take screenshots of your ride details, including start/end times, route, and any malfunction reports in the app.
Do not give recorded statements or sign anything without legal advice. They may use your words against you.
Early investigation is critical—especially when government entities or corporations are involved.
Electric scooter accidents aren't "minor" just because the vehicle is small. Liability may rest with a driver, a scooter company, a city, or multiple parties at once.
If you were injured in a scooter accident in California, understanding who can be held responsible is the first step toward protecting your rights and recovering full compensation.
Need Help with a Scooter Accident Claim?
Our experienced personal injury attorneys understand the complexities of scooter accident cases and can help you navigate the legal process.
Get a Free Consultation