Breathalyzers Are Inaccurate. Here Is Why: Has a Bad Situation Upended Your Life? Don't Face it Alone. 

Breathalyzers Are Inaccurate. Here Is Why:

In what could have been a landmark DUI case, the United State Supreme Court refused to consider a strong challenge to the reliability of breathalyzer results. The ruling is a blow against defendants who intend to argue that breathalyzers are inaccurate at trial in their in DUI cases. In essence, the United States Supreme Court has denied the ability of DUI defendants to introduce relevant facts at trial.

The case originated in San Diego, where a trial court prevented the defendant, Terry Vangelder, from using an expert to testify that breathalyzers are inaccurate. Mr. Vangelder was subsequently convicted of drunk driving by a California jury. Vangelder appealed, however The California Supreme Court upheld the trial court’s decision. Mr. Vangelder then appealed to The United State Supreme Court.

There was hope among the California DUI defense bar that The United State Supreme Court would hear the case. But instead, The United State Supreme Court denied review of Mr. Vangelder’s case. Thus, the California Supreme Court’s decision remains and the precedent stants. This means that California DUI defendants lack the ability to exercise their right to introduce evidence broadly challenging the accuracy of breathalyzers in DUI cases. Defendants are not allowed to argue that breathalyzers are inaccurate in general, they may only attack the particular breathalyzer machine used in their case.

While the ruling is a disappointment, we have made a point to remind our clients that there are still dozens of ways in which to successfully attack DUI charges in general. Further, DUI defendants still have the ability to question the accuracy of the particular breathalyzer used in their arrest. As it stands, DUI defendants may not introduce evidence that breathalyzers are  inaccurate. (Despite mountains of evidence to the contrary.)

For those that contend that Breathalyzers are in fact reliable: See LaBianca, “The Myth of Breath Test Accuracy What the Studies Have Really Shown,” 5 DWI Journal: Law & Science 11 (November 1990). “For every one degree centigrade change in alveolar air temperature, the conversion ratio, and the percent blood alcohol content changes by 6.5%.”

I also suggest you check  out Jones, “How Breathing Technique Can Influence the Results of Breath Alcohol Analysis,” 22 Med. Sci. Law 275-280 (1982) Breathalyzers are inaccurate for a number of reasons, perhaps most significantly because they treat every person as if they have the same body chemistry, which is complete nonsense. Every single person is different, in a way that can have a significant impact on the results of a breath test.


Common Questions

  • National Geographic
  • Bar Association of San Francisco
  • Berkeley Law
  • Duke Law
  • Lawyerist
  • Lawyernomics
  • Cision
  • Best of SF Winner
  • The National Trial Lawyers
  • 2020 Northern California Rising Stars Super Lawyer Award
  • 2019 Northern California Rising Stars Super Lawyer Award
  • 2018 Northern California Rising Stars Super Lawyer Award
  • 2017 Northern California Rising Stars Super Lawyer Award
  • Elite Lawyer for 2020

Each Year, We Protect Hundreds of Clients' Futures

Explore Our Practice Areas & See How We Can Help You

More Than 150 5-Star Reviews

See What Our Clients Are Saying About Us
    Best DUI lawyers in Los Angeles.

    “I love Jason. He helped me figure out what to do in a difficult situation. He’s the best with a cherry on top. Seriously, these guys rock.”

    - Staci M.
    The best DUI attorney in San Francisco!

    “Jason has more trial experience than anyone I have ever met and has more experience than anybody in the courthouse and seems to know everyone there. My outcome was incredibly positive! I couldn't ask for a better attorney.”

    - Subhi B.
    Super impressed with Jason's team and wholeheartedly recommend his firm.

    “Very, very easy to work with, and a seamless experience on a routine traffic violation. All electronic, easy communication, and consistent updates during the process.”

    - Mike G.
    Definitely hire Jason.

    “All charges were dropped. And the process was simple. I didn’t have to file paperwork, go to the courthouse, or deal with anything. Jason and his staff managed the whole affair. I’m so grateful!”

    - Rebecca B.
    Best decision I have ever made!

    “Jason helped me with my case in a professional and proficient manner. I will definitely come to Jason in the future for any upcoming issues I may have.”

    - Sara P.

What Sets Us Apart?

  • Personal Representation

    You work directly with your attorney every step of the way.

  • Virtual Services

    We utilize technology so you don't need to come into the office and in most cases, court.

  • Connected to the Local Community

    We have built close professional relationships with local judges and district attorneys and are deeply involved in the community.

  • Quick Response

    We get great results, and we get them fast!

Has a Bad Situation Upended Your Life?

Don’t Face it Alone.

How Can We Help You?

You can contact us using this form day or night, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. You will hear back from one of our attorneys the same day or next day.
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.